Download In Defense of Elitism by William A. Henry PDF

By William A. Henry

From the Pulitzer Prize-winning tradition critic  for Time journal comes the  tremendously arguable, but hugely persuasive,  argument that our devotion to the largely  unexamined delusion of egalitarianism lies on the middle of the  ongoing "dumbing of America."

Americans have consistently stubbornly clung to the  myth of egalitarianism, of the supremacy of the  individual general guy. yet right here, at lengthy last,  Pulitzer Prize-winning critic William A. Henry III  takes on, and debunks, a few easy, fundamentally  ingrained rules: that everybody is pretty well alike  (and may still be); that self-fulfillment is more  imortant thant goal success; that everyone  has anything major to give a contribution; that all  cultures provide anything both priceless; that  a really simply society might immediately produce  equal good fortune effects throughout strains of race,  class, and gender; and that the typical guy is almost  always correct. Henry makes transparent, in a e-book complete of  vivid examples and unflinching reviews, that  while those notions are seductively democratic they  are additionally hopelessly mistaken.

Show description

Read Online or Download In Defense of Elitism PDF

Best poverty books

Broke, USA: From Pawnshops to Poverty, Inc.--How the Working Poor Became Big Business

For many humans, the nice Crash of 2008 has intended troubling occasions. now not so for these within the flourishing poverty undefined, for whom the commercial woes spell a chance to extend and develop. those mercenary marketers have taken good thing about an period of deregulation to plan pricey items to promote to the credit-hungry operating terrible, together with the moment tax refund and the payday personal loan.

All That Is Solid: The Great Housing Disaster

Housing was once on the middle of the monetary cave in, and our economic system is now precariously reliant at the housing marketplace. during this groundbreaking new booklet, Danny Dorling argues that housing is the defining factor of our occasions. Tracing how we obtained to our present situation and the way housing has come to mirror category and wealth in Britain, All that's stable noticeably indicates that the answer to our difficulties - emerging homelessness, a iteration priced out of domestic possession - isn't, as is commonly assumed, development extra houses.

Swept Up Lives: Re-envisioning the Homeless City (RGS-IBG Book Series)

Using leading edge ethnographic study, Swept Up Lives? demanding situations traditional money owed of city homelessness to track the complicated and sundry makes an attempt to take care of homeless humans provides leading edge ethnographic learn which implies a major shift in point of view within the research and realizing of city homelessnessEmphasizes the moral and emotional geographies of care embodied and played inside homeless providers spacesSuggests that diverse homelessness ‘scenes’ advance somewhere else as a result of various historic, political, and cultural responses to the issues confronted

Stories from the Street: A Theology of Homelessness

Tales from the road is a theological exploration of interviews with women and men who had skilled homelessness all through their lives. Framed inside a theology of tale and a theology of liberation, Nixon means that tale is not just a car for growing human transformation however it is one among God's selected technique of effecting switch.

Extra resources for In Defense of Elitism

Sample text

The Russian smiles slyly and says, “In my village, I have a neighbor who has a cow. I do not have a cow. ” The point of elitism is not, when all is said and done, to promote envy or to enlarge the numbers of society’s losers. It is to provide sufficient rewards for winning, and sufficient support for ideas that have shaped past progress and that might aid future progress so that society as a whole wins—that is, gets richer, better educated, more productive, and healthier. There is plenty of room for upward mobility in such a system.

In the effort to wish it so, we have warpingly redefined contribution and reduced its meaning. It is not necessarily a conspiracy of silence that the historical record is so thin in detailing women painters and writers of the early Renaissance or black nuclear physicists and Hispanic political leaders of the early twentieth century. Sometimes the record is thin because the accomplishments were too. I expect many people will reflexively find these observations racist. But I am not asserting that, say, people of African descent cannot compete equally—only that their ancestral culture did not give them the tools and opportunity to do so.

For the most part, games and scores are avoided altogether in favor of self-development. Running is not necessarily timed; basketball hoops are adjusted in height and distance to fit each pupil’s capacity. The point is not to measure oneself against absolute standards but to feel good about exercise and taking part. That is about as concise and benign an embodiment of egalitarianism as I can imagine. And I still think it is pernicious. Elitists of equal misguidedness, and some of outright menace, permeate American society.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.25 of 5 – based on 35 votes